What Constitutes the “Oakmont Community”?

Oakmont Aerial View

Opinion and Gemini Question and Response

OVA President, Steve Spanier, yesterday published a President’s Message entitled “Elections Have Consequences”. While much of what he has to say is what I would characterize as “motherhood and apple pie”, i.e. things that we all are likely to agree on, I was rather shocked by his assertion that the Oakmont community is “not the individuals who currently live here”! My personal belief is that the Oakmont community is defined by the individuals who currently own property here, i.e. all OVA members.

I will not express my views further below, but I will instead share with you the query which I posed to Gemini, my most commonly used AI chatbot, and Gemini’s response. I will leave it to the reader to decide whether that response is fair and balanced. For anyone interested, I suggest that you pose a similar question, or whatever question interests you, to Gemini or any of its AI chatbot competitors.

My Query

I live in a California HOA called Oakmont, and the Oakmont Village Association is responsible for architectural standards and for maintaining the recreational amenities of the community. The Board president recently published a message containing the following: “Clarity on this point comes from understanding that Oakmont – not the individuals who currently live here – is the community in question. Oakmont residents come and go, but the community will hopefully outlast us all and continue to serve those who move here long into the future.” This is remarkable to me because would have said that the community is the individuals who own homes in Oakmont, but the president is saying that the community is not the collective membership. He seems to be saying that the community is the common property, the staff that maintains it and Board that governs it. Is this consistent with California HOA law?

Gemini’s Response

From a strict legal standpoint under California law, the Board president’s philosophical framing is inaccurate and turns the legal structure of a homeowners association upside down.

While the president’s statement is likely an attempt to emphasize long-term stewardship of the physical property, it fundamentally misrepresents who an HOA legally is under California statutes.

The Legal Reality: Who is the HOA?

In California, a common interest development (CID) association—such as the Oakmont Village Association—is governed primarily by two bodies of law: the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act (Civil Code § 4000 et seq.) and the California Nonprofit Mutual Benefit Corporation Law (Corporations Code § 7110 et seq.).

  1. The Association Is the Membership: Under California law, an association is defined as a nonprofit corporation created for the purpose of managing a common interest development. Crucially, a mutual benefit corporation exists exclusively to advance the common interests of its members. Those members are the property owners. Membership is appurtenant to and inseparable from home ownership. Legally speaking, the corporation has no independent soul, identity, or existence separate from the collective body of homeowners who own the properties.
  2. The Board Are Fiduciaries, Not Rulers: The Board of Directors does not “own” or embody Oakmont. Directors are elected representatives legally bound by a strict fiduciary duty under Corporations Code § 5231 to act in good faith and in the best interests of the corporation and its members. They are agents of the homeowners, hired (via election) to maintain common areas and enforce rules—not an autonomous entity sitting above the community.
  3. The Property and Assets Belong to the Members: Common areas and amenities are held by the association on behalf of the members. If the corporation were ever legally dissolved (under strict statutory oversight), the common assets do not revert to the board or staff; they are distributed to or managed for the benefit of the members.

Dissecting the President’s Rhetoric

Why would a board president say something that contradicts corporate and property law?

  • The Stewardship Argument (The Intent): Board presidents often use this phrasing to justify unpopular long-term decisions—such as large special assessments for reserve funds, capital improvements, or infrastructure repairs. The underlying message is: “Don’t just think about your short-term wallet; think about the 50-year health of the community.” In that narrow, rhetorical sense, physical infrastructure and financial reserves do outlast individual residents.
  • The Governance Trap (The Risk): When a board begins to view itself as “Oakmont” distinct from the residents (“the community in question”), it often signals an insular administrative mindset. It creates an unhealthy “us versus them” dynamic where resident feedback, democratic dissent, or homeowner inquiries are treated as temporary nuisances rather than the voices of the actual owners of the corporation.

In short, residents do come and go, but while they live there, they are the association. The board and staff are merely the temporary caretakers hired to manage it.


Share this page:

13 Comments

  1. Norbert Tenenbaum on November 15, 2026 at 10:58 am

    Norbert

  2. Elihu on November 15, 2026 at 11:24 am

    Thank you Bruce for the reminder and emphasis on the legal fiduciary responsibility of the OVA Board and President Spanier, in case they have forgotten it as their actions and statements might indicate.

  3. Don McPherson on November 15, 2026 at 11:34 am

    Thanks, Bruce. Very illuminating. FWIW, I queried ChatGPT. The response is very lengthy but very comprehensive.

    My query: “Please analyze the following statement by the Oakmont Village Association President for accuracy and consistency with California law governing Home Owners’ Associations”

    ChatGPT Response:

    I will analyze it against California law governing common-interest developments and homeowners’ associations, with particular attention to the Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act (California Civil Code §§ 4000–6150).

    My analysis will cover:
    1. Legal accuracy: Whether the President’s statements correctly describe California law.
    2. Statutory compliance: Whether the statements are consistent with applicable sections of the California Civil Code.
    3. Board authority: Whether the President or Board has the authority to take the actions described.
    4. Governing documents: Whether the statements are consistent with the HOA’s CC&Rs, bylaws, and operating rules, where relevant.
    5. Member rights: Whether the statements accurately reflect homeowners’ rights concerning voting, meetings, records access, assessments, enforcement, and due process.
    6. Potential violations: Whether any statements misrepresent the law, improperly restrict homeowner rights, or expose the Association to legal challenges.
    I will distinguish between:
    – What California law actually requires.
    – What the Association is permitted to do.
    – What the Association may do only if authorized by its governing documents.
    – What appears legally questionable or potentially unlawful.
    I will provide specific California Civil Code references and links to authoritative legal sources, and identify where the President’s interpretation may be misleading or incorrect.

    I will also distinguish definitive legal requirements from issues that depend on the particular wording of Oakmont’s governing documents.

    Legal analysis of the Oakmont Village Association President’s statement

    Overall assessment: The President’s statement contains several sound principles of HOA governance, but it also makes a significant legal assertion that deserves closer examination. In particular, the assertion that a board member’s fiduciary responsibility is to preserve and improve “Oakmont” as a continuing community, rather than to represent the interests and rights of the people who currently own homes and belong to the Association, needs qualification under California law.

    The distinction is important. An HOA board is not simply a group of community planners or long-term stewards. It is a governing body entrusted with legal, financial, and fiduciary responsibilities to the Association and its members.

    I would divide the analysis into three categories:
    Statements that accurately reflect good HOA governance.
    Statements that are reasonable opinions but are not necessarily legal requirements.
    Statements that could misrepresent or oversimplify the legal duties of HOA directors.

    The principal legal framework is California’s Davis-Stirling Common Interest Development Act, the California Corporations Code provisions governing nonprofit mutual benefit corporations, and applicable California court decisions.
    1. Best Practice #1: The Community Comes First
    This is the most important section from a legal standpoint.
    The President writes:
    “Oakmont – not the individuals who currently live here – is the community in question.”
    And later:
    “That is the fiduciary responsibility the law requires of all HOA board members.”
    What California law actually says
    Oakmont Village Association is a California nonprofit mutual benefit corporation. Its legal identity as a corporation is important because its directors are subject to California Corporations Code § 7231.
    That statute establishes three fundamental requirements:
    Directors must act in good faith.
    Directors must act in a manner they believe to be in the best interests of the corporation.
    Directors must exercise the care, including reasonable inquiry, that an ordinarily prudent person in a similar position would exercise under similar circumstances.
    Oakmont’s board therefore does have a legal obligation to consider the interests of the Association as a whole, rather than simply voting according to personal preferences or the demands of individual friends and neighbors.

    However, the President’s description of the beneficiary of that fiduciary responsibility is incomplete.
    The distinction is between the Association as a legal corporation and the physical community as an evolving place.
    The corporation exists to serve the purposes established by its articles of incorporation, bylaws, CC&Rs, and applicable law. It is not an independent entity with unlimited authority to pursue whatever vision of Oakmont’s future a particular board happens to favor.

    The California Supreme Court addressed directors’ fiduciary obligations in Frances T. v. Village Green Owners Association (1986), 42 Cal.3d 490. The Court explained that directors of nonprofit corporations are fiduciaries and must exercise due care and undivided loyalty in the interests of the corporation.

    Justia Law
    +1
    The California Supreme Court subsequently addressed HOA board decision-making in Lamden v. La Jolla Shores Clubdominium Homeowners Association (1999), 21 Cal.4th 249.
    The Court recognized that a board’s discretionary decisions deserve judicial deference when the board:
    Is properly constituted.
    Conducts a reasonable investigation.
    Acts in good faith.
    Considers the best interests of the Association and its members.
    Acts within its authority under applicable statutes and governing documents.

    California Supreme Court Resources
    That fifth requirement is particularly important. A board cannot justify an otherwise unauthorized action by arguing that it believes the action will benefit Oakmont’s future.
    The problem with the President’s formulation
    There is a potentially significant difference between these two propositions:
    The board should make decisions that benefit the Association and its membership as a whole.
    The board should make decisions based on its own vision of what will make Oakmont desirable to future residents, even when those decisions conflict with the interests or preferences of current members.
    The first proposition is consistent with California law. The second is not an adequate statement of the directors’ legal responsibilities.
    Current members are not merely temporary occupants whose interests can be subordinated to an abstract vision of the future. They are the people whose membership, assessments, voting rights, and other interests are governed by the Association.
    Future residents may benefit from sound long-term planning, prudent financial management, and responsible maintenance. But the President’s statement does not establish that future residents have a superior legal claim to the Association’s consideration.

    My conclusion on Best Practice #1: The general principle is sound, but the President’s explanation of fiduciary responsibility is legally incomplete and potentially misleading. The proper formulation is that directors must act in the best interests of the Association, consistently with its legal purposes, governing documents, applicable law, and the interests and rights of its members.

    2. Best Practice #2: Dedication and Commitment
    The President writes that board members must read board packets, attend meetings, research difficult issues, and devote sufficient time to their responsibilities.

    Generally consistent with California law
    This is good advice, and it has a legal foundation.
    Corporations Code § 7231 establishes a duty of care. Directors cannot simply accept management’s recommendations, ignore important information, or routinely approve matters without reasonable consideration.
    The duty of care is not satisfied merely by attending meetings and casting votes.
    It can require directors to:
    Review financial statements and budgets.
    Understand proposed expenditures and contracts.
    Ask questions about significant decisions.
    Investigate material concerns.
    Evaluate recommendations from management and committees.
    Understand the consequences of decisions affecting members.

    The President is also correct that directors are volunteers and that the position need not consume their entire lives.
    Nevertheless, volunteer status does not eliminate fiduciary obligations.
    A director who is unwilling or unable to devote reasonable attention to the Association’s business may have difficulty fulfilling those obligations.

    There is one important distinction: California law does not establish a fixed number of hours that directors must devote to their duties. The standard is reasonable care under the circumstances.

    My conclusion on Best Practice #2: Accurate and consistent with California law.

    3. Best Practice #3: A Good Team Player
    The President emphasizes that each director has one vote and that board members should listen, respect differing opinions, and work together.
    Sound governance advice

    The basic proposition is correct.

    A director is one member of a collective governing body. The board generally acts through properly authorized collective decisions, not through the independent wishes of individual directors.
    However, there is an important distinction between being a good team player and being obligated to support the majority.

    California law does not require a director to agree with the other directors.
    A director’s obligation is to exercise independent judgment and fulfill his or her fiduciary responsibilities.
    For example, a director should not:
    Vote for a proposal simply because the other six directors support it.
    Suppress a legitimate objection to maintain board harmony.
    Ignore evidence that a proposed action violates the governing documents.
    Support an expenditure merely to avoid offending other directors.
    Place loyalty to the board majority above the director’s legal responsibilities.
    Indeed, there may be circumstances in which the most responsible director is the one who votes against the majority.

    There is also a procedural consideration. Under the Davis-Stirling Act, Civil Code § 4935, board meetings generally must be open to members, subject to specified executive-session exceptions. Members have statutory participation rights under Civil Code § 4925.

    A board’s internal preference for harmony cannot be used to circumvent these requirements or improperly exclude member participation.

    My conclusion on Best Practice #3: Good advice, provided that teamwork means constructive deliberation rather than unquestioning support for the board majority.

    4. Conclusion: The Importance of Experience and Knowledge of HOA Law
    The President writes:
    “Although they’re certainly helpful, I don’t believe vast community experience and knowledge of HOA law are as important as some may believe. These can be acquired through dedication and commitment to the job.”

    This is perhaps the second most important statement in the article from a governance standpoint.
    Is it legally accurate?

    There is no general California statutory requirement that an HOA director possess previous board experience, professional management experience, or a legal background.
    So, in that narrow sense, the President is correct.

    However, the statement risks understating the importance of legal knowledge and competence.
    Corporations Code § 7231 requires directors to exercise reasonable care and conduct reasonable inquiries. This is an affirmative obligation, not simply a recommendation to learn as they go.
    The statute permits directors to rely on competent professionals, including attorneys, accountants, and other experts, when appropriate. But reliance is conditional: directors must act in good faith, conduct reasonable inquiry when circumstances indicate a need, and not rely on information they know is unreliable.

    FindLaw
    For Oakmont, this is particularly important because the Association deals with substantial financial obligations, common facilities, contracts, assessments, property maintenance, member rights, and a complex collection of governing documents.
    A director does not need to be an attorney. But a director should understand:
    The basic requirements of the Davis-Stirling Act.
    The Association’s articles of incorporation and bylaws.
    The CC&Rs and their restrictions on board authority.
    The distinction between board authority and membership authority.
    The requirements for open meetings and executive sessions.
    The financial and fiduciary responsibilities of directors.
    The rights of members to participate in Association governance.

    My conclusion: Prior experience and professional expertise are not prerequisites for election, but an understanding of HOA law and governance is essential to competent board service. Directors must acquire sufficient knowledge to fulfill their legal obligations, whether before taking office or through diligent education afterward.

    5. An important omission: The President does not adequately address the rights of Association members
    This is a significant weakness in an article about good HOA governance.

    The entire discussion focuses on what board members should do for the community, how they should work together, and how they should exercise their authority.

    There is remarkably little discussion of the people who elect the board and whose money and property interests the Association governs.

    California law gives members specific rights that are not merely matters of board courtesy.
    For example:
    California law
    Member right
    Civil Code § 4925
    Right to attend open board meetings and speak at meetings, subject to reasonable time limits
    Civil Code § 4935
    Limits the subjects that may be discussed in executive session
    Civil Code §§ 5200–5240
    Rights to inspect and copy specified Association records
    Civil Code § 5100
    Secret-ballot procedures for specified elections and other matters
    Civil Code § 5105
    Election rules, candidate access, and protections for election-related communications
    Civil Code § 5115
    Election notice and ballot distribution requirements

    Justia Law
    +3
    These rights are important because HOA governance is not simply a matter of seven directors deciding what they believe is best.
    The board exercises authority within a statutory and contractual framework that protects the membership.
    For example, Civil Code § 4925 expressly provides that members may attend board meetings and that the board must permit members to speak, subject to reasonable time limits.

    Justia Law
    Similarly, election rules must provide equal access to Association media and common-area meeting facilities for candidates and members advocating different points of view, including those not endorsed by the board.

    Justia Law
    These are substantive legal protections, not optional elements of good public relations.

    My observation: A discussion of good HOA governance that emphasizes board members’ responsibility to the community but gives little attention to members’ statutory rights is incomplete.

    6. An important distinction: The board is not the community

    I believe this is the central issue raised by the President’s article.

    The board is entrusted with managing the Association. It does not own the community, and its members are not authorized to substitute their personal vision for the rights and interests of the Association’s membership.

    The distinction can be summarized as follows:
    The board’s legitimate responsibility
    What the board cannot assume
    Protect the Association’s financial health
    That its preferred financial priorities are automatically correct
    Maintain and improve common facilities
    That every proposed improvement is authorized
    Plan for Oakmont’s long-term future

    That future residents’ hypothetical preferences override present legal obligations
    Consider the interests of the membership as a whole

    That dissenting members’ interests can be disregarded
    Exercise reasonable discretion
    That its decisions are beyond legal scrutiny
    Work collectively as a board

    That individual directors must surrender independent judgment
    The California Supreme Court’s decision in Lamden is particularly relevant here.
    The Court did not give HOA boards unlimited discretion. Its judicial-deference standard specifically requires good faith, reasonable investigation, consideration of the Association’s and its members’ best interests, and action within the board’s legal authority.

    California Supreme Court Resources
    That is a considerably more demanding standard than simply doing what the board believes will make Oakmont a more desirable place to live.

    7. Oakmont-specific considerations
    There is another reason the President’s wording deserves scrutiny.

    Oakmont Village Association is not simply an informal neighborhood organization. It is a nonprofit corporation with defined legal purposes and governing documents.

    OVA’s published election rules identify it as a California nonprofit corporation governed by the Davis-Stirling Act.

    Oakmont Village
    Its Articles of Incorporation identify providing athletic, recreational, and club facilities for members and their guests as a primary corporate purpose.

    Granicus
    That corporate purpose matters.
    The board must consider the Association’s actual legal purposes, not just an aspirational concept of what will make Oakmont attractive to future homeowners.

    This does not mean the board cannot plan for the future. It certainly can and should. But long-term planning must remain consistent with the Association’s governing documents and applicable law.

    I would also recommend examining three existing OVA documents when evaluating the President’s governance philosophy:
    OVA’s Articles of Incorporation and Bylaws.
    OVA’s Board of Directors Code of Conduct.
    OVA’s Board Mission Statement and Goals.
    These documents are available through the Association’s official document library.

    I have not undertaken a clause-by-clause comparison of those documents with the President’s article, so I would not characterize the article itself as violating any particular OVA provision.

    8. Overall assessment
    Here is my assessment of the five principal propositions in the President’s article.

    Statement or proposition
    Assessment
    Community interests should take priority over personal interests.
    Legally sound, with qualifications.

    Directors should consider Oakmont’s long-term future.
    Sound governance practice, but not an unlimited legal mandate.

    Directors must demonstrate dedication and commitment.
    Consistent with their statutory duty of care.

    Directors should be good team players.
    Good advice, provided independent judgment is preserved.

    Experience and knowledge of HOA law are less important than dedication.
    Partially correct, but understates directors’ legal obligations.

    Fiduciary responsibility means preserving Oakmont for future residents.
    Incomplete and potentially misleading description of California law.

    Most important legal concern
    The statement that Oakmont, rather than its current residents, is the community in question is not an accurate substitute for the fiduciary standard established by California law.
    Directors must act in the best interests of the Association, exercise reasonable care, and respect the rights of its members. They may consider future residents and long-term community interests, but they cannot use those considerations to disregard the Association’s legal purposes, governing documents, or current members’ legal rights.

    9. What I believe the President should have said
    A more legally accurate description of the fiduciary responsibility of OVA directors would be:

    The fundamental responsibility of an OVA board member is to act in the best interests of the Oakmont Village Association, consistent with its Articles of Incorporation, Bylaws, CC&Rs, and applicable California law. This responsibility requires directors to consider the long-term financial health and sustainability of the Association, the maintenance and quality of its facilities, and the interests and rights of its current membership.
    While directors should consider the interests of future residents and the long-term desirability of Oakmont, they must not substitute their personal vision of Oakmont’s future for their legal obligations to the Association and its members.

    Each director must exercise independent judgment, make informed decisions, act in good faith, conduct reasonable inquiries, and respect the rights of members to participate in Association governance. Directors should work collaboratively, but neither board consensus nor personal loyalty to fellow directors can supersede their individual fiduciary obligations.

    10. My final opinion

    I would not characterize the President’s article as an outright misstatement of California law. Much of it is sensible advice about volunteering, dedication, cooperation, and long-term stewardship.

    However, I see three important shortcomings:

    First: It conflates the interests of the physical Oakmont community with the legal interests of the Oakmont Village Association and its membership.

    Second: It does not adequately acknowledge that the board’s authority is constrained by California law, the governing documents, and the rights of Association members.

    Third: It understates the importance of directors understanding their legal responsibilities. Dedication and good intentions are not substitutes for legal compliance, reasonable inquiry, and independent judgment.

    I would be particularly concerned if the President’s philosophy were interpreted to mean that directors should disregard the preferences or objections of current members whenever the board believes it is pursuing a better future for Oakmont.

    That is not what California’s fiduciary-duty standard says.

    A board member’s responsibility is not to govern Oakmont according to his or her personal vision of what Oakmont should become. It is to govern the Association responsibly, lawfully, and in the best interests of the Association and its members.

    That is the distinction I believe Oakmont homeowners should keep in mind as they evaluate candidates in the upcoming election.

    Principal legal references
    For further examination, these are the most useful authorities:
    California Corporations Code § 7231 — Directors’ standard of care and fiduciary responsibilities.
    Frances T. v. Village Green Owners Association (1986) — California Supreme Court discussion of HOA director fiduciary duties.
    Lamden v. La Jolla Shores Clubdominium Homeowners Association (1999) — Judicial deference to properly exercised HOA board discretion.
    California Civil Code § 4925 — Member attendance and participation rights.
    California Civil Code § 4935 — Executive-session limitations.
    California Civil Code § 5105 — HOA election rules and candidate protections.
    Legal qualification: This is an independent analysis of the published statement, not a legal opinion based on a complete review of OVA’s current governing documents or the facts surrounding any particular board decision. The statutory provisions and cases cited provide the legal framework, but applying them to a specific OVA dispute may require advice from a California HOA attorney.

    • Bruce Bon on November 15, 2026 at 2:04 pm

      Wow! That is an extensive analysis. I imagine, after several of us have raised issues with his statement, Steve would probably agree that it would have been better had he asked ChatGPT for an analysis *before* he published his message, and then modified his message accordingly, albeit not to be as detailed as the ChatGPT response.

      • Don McPherson on November 15, 2026 at 2:53 pm

        Yes. And it’s more than a bit scary that the work time for the analysis and generation of output was 27 seconds.

        Interestingly, immediately following its analysis ChatGTP made this suggestion and offer, which I didn’t copy into the comment:

        “One additional suggestion: Given that this statement was published in the run-up to the 2027 OVA board election, there is an opportunity to turn this analysis into a constructive response for Oakmont homeowners—one that distinguishes the President’s personal governance philosophy from the actual fiduciary duties imposed on elected directors by California law. I can help draft that response as a homeowner commentary suitable for publication in the Oakmont News.”

        So, I asked it to go ahead and draft within the word limits of the Oakmont News.

        This was the response:

        “The Oakmont News currently limits letters to the editor to 250 words. Its guidelines require your name and Oakmont address (the address is not published). Letters may be edited for length and spelling but are not edited for accuracy.
        Oakmont Village

        I recommend a respectful but substantive response. Rather than accuse the President of violating the law, the letter should challenge the interpretation of fiduciary responsibility and emphasize the rights of homeowners.

        Here is my proposed submission.
        Good HOA Governance: Who Does the Board Serve?

        The President’s recent article on HOA governance raises important issues, but one statement deserves clarification. The President writes that “Oakmont – not the individuals who currently live here – is the community in question,” and identifies this philosophy as the board’s fiduciary responsibility.

        California law draws a more precise distinction. Under Corporations Code § 7231, HOA directors must act in good faith, exercise reasonable care, and act in the best interests of the corporation. In Lamden v. La Jolla Shores (1999), the California Supreme Court recognized appropriate deference to board decisions made in good faith, after reasonable investigation, and within the board’s authority.

        Planning for Oakmont’s future is certainly appropriate. But the Association is not an abstract concept whose future can be pursued at the expense of its present membership. Directors must respect the Association’s governing documents, statutory obligations, and the rights and interests of current homeowners.

        Good governance also requires independent judgment. Being a team player does not mean automatically supporting the majority, and dedication cannot substitute for understanding one’s legal responsibilities.

        As we approach the board election, let’s look for candidates who combine long-term vision with transparency, accountability, informed decision-making, and respect for homeowners’ rights.

        Oakmont’s future matters. So do the people who live here today.

        Under 250 words
        Approximately 217 words, including the headline.
        Why I recommend this approach
        Three things make this response effective:

        1. It challenges the central premise without making it personal. You question the President’s interpretation of fiduciary responsibility rather than his motives or character.

        2. It introduces actual legal standards. Corporations Code § 7231 and the Lamden decision give the argument a foundation beyond personal disagreement.

        3. It makes the election relevant. It asks homeowners to evaluate candidates on transparency, accountability, legal competence, and respect for members.

        One particularly important point is the closing sentence. It captures the fundamental distinction between long-term stewardship and the obligation to serve the current membership.

        I would submit this version substantially as written.”

        Pretty good I think. I will not send this letter b/c I do not use a chatbot to write my stuff.

        The example does illustrate, though, some of the problems of plagiarism in the AI world — upon reading the ChatGPT-drafted response, especially for example, the next to last paragraph of the chatbot’s response, the problem of un-remembering this felicitous formulation of words and writing originally……

        • Don McPherson on November 15, 2026 at 3:04 pm

          What I did do, instead, was to email the ChatGPT analysis to Steve, copied to Board members and Christel, without judgment — as you did above with your Gemini — inviting their independent consideration of the adequacy of my query and the fairness, balance, accuracy and consistency of the ChatGPT analysis and conclusions.

          • Bruce Bon on November 15, 2026 at 3:35 pm

            Nice work! I would have been very tempted to send the ChatGPT suggestion into the Oakmont News as a letter — I can recognize eloquence that exceeds my own! And, of course, legal research.

            I think that Steve’s sincere conviction, as expressed in his message, is that management of OVA is similar in many respects to management of a resort, with emphasis on long term property values and, thus, on appeal to future prospective buyers, than on what the current owners want. Some of us current owners have very similar priorities, but many of us are more concerned with stability and affordability — we want to be able to live here in peace and harmony for as long as we can, without worrying about the cost and risks of huge loans or the upheaval of large construction projects. The key point where I think Steve gets it wrong is that, as a director and as president, he works for us, not for future residents who haven’t arrived yet. As both Gemini and ChatGPT point out, his direct legal responsibility is to current owners. But he is not willing to even ask current owners what they want in a comprehensive survey, for fear of our will being contrary to what he considers the best interests of the community, much less to give them a direct vote on capital improvement issues! This is unfortunate, because in many other respects he is one of our more competent and honest leaders, but for me, this anti-democratic attitude is a make-or-break issue — I can never vote for him.



    • Deborah Quam on November 16, 2026 at 11:07 am

      Thank-you!!!

  4. John MacInnis on November 15, 2026 at 12:17 pm

    A I quiries are helpful for those issues that may have some differing interpretations. The FIDUCIARY duties of directors is basic and one that has been “tested” in may court decisions and several CA corp codes.

    https://findhoalaw.com/fiduciary-duties-of-directors/

    John MacInnis – Oakmont Dr.

  5. Timothy Nelson on November 15, 2026 at 11:17 pm

    OVA President Steve Spanier’s latest message, “Elections Have Consequences,” contained a remarkable revelation: the Oakmont community is not the individuals who currently live here.

    This bold reimagining of geography and community should not be overlooked. By this logic, the San Francisco 49ers are not really the players on the field but everyone who might someday buy a ticket, and a restaurant’s customers are the people who might decide make a reservation next year.

    It is heartening to know Steve is championing the interests of absentee landlords and the vast, overlooked population of Oakmont residents who don’t actually reside in Oakmont… yet. One can only marvel at the possibilities. Once Steve figures out how to collect dues from all those future residents, Oakmont’s finances will be headed for a golden age. In fact, I can’t wait to see just how low our dues become once payments start rolling in from people who haven’t bought homes here yet. And think how many more votes Steve will get after those future homeowners start voting in elections before they move in.

    Such visionary leadership transcends the conventional meaning of both “community” and “living here.”

  6. Eric Engdahl on November 16, 2026 at 9:46 am

    Thanks for these. I always feel patronized by Spanier’s commentaries – as though he were talking to the “old people.” I appreciate the reminder that he works for the current residents who elected him – not the future “community.”

    Eric Engdahl

  7. Don McPherson on November 16, 2026 at 10:30 am

    Given the set table for some major financial decisions regarding Berger and beyond, the timing of the President’s expansive view of the ‘Oakmont community’ makes Gemini’s rhetorical analysis worth reflecting:

    “ Why would a board president say something that contradicts corporate and property law?

    The Stewardship Argument (The Intent): Board presidents often use this phrasing to justify unpopular long-term decisions—such as large special assessments for reserve funds, capital improvements, or infrastructure repairs. The underlying message is: “Don’t just think about your short-term wallet; think about the 50-year health of the community.””

  8. Lorrie Kempf on November 16, 2026 at 1:37 pm

    Thank you!

Leave a Comment