A ‘Vital Threat to Oakmont,’ a Decade in the Making
This statistic shows the number of participants in golf in the United States from 2006 to 2016. In 2016, the number of participants (aged six years and older) in golf amounted to approximately 23.82 million
This article I wrote in 2005 describing the challenges facing the Oakmont Golf Club, reads almost as if written today.
And former OGC Board member, John Williston just recently comments, “I have repeatedly tried to get the community interested in this potentially vital threat to Oakmont for almost ten years and am happy to see that there has finally been a response.”
Ten years ago is when OGC borrowed $3.4 mm to pay back the bondholders/equity owners, who invested their monies to build the Quail Inn and the pro shop.
——————-
Yvonne Frauenfelder | Kenwood Press, April 2005
For more than a year rumors have swirled around the Oakmont Golf Club, the anxiety palpable in the air. Word got around that 3.4 million dollars in notes to golf club members were due in 2005 and nobody knew how to raise the money. Some residents of the community were afraid that the Oakmont Village Association might buy the golf courses, or help the club out and assess every house a certain fee to make the deal possible. Worse, condominiums dotting the greens were mentioned in hushed gossip.
Memories of the “civil war” that pitted resident against resident and developer against the common good in 1988 elicited fear and uncertainty among many villagers. And, indeed, the situation was becoming precarious about a year ago when informal talks took place with the OVA, financial institutions, and the city of Santa Rosa as a potential purchaser of the golf courses.
Once a flourishing restaurant, the newly rebuilt clubhouse and restaurant became a drain on the “for profit” Golf Club Corporation. People complained that the food was not nearly as good as it used to be, and the formal dining room closed down.
In order to quell these rumors and to obtain accurate information, I met with the president of the Golf Club, Tony Jenks, First of all, he corrected the assumptions that the notes were due this year – they are not until 2008 – and secondly “surprise” the Golf Club is getting out of the business of running the facilities. A management company has taken over the functions of both the golf courses and the Quail Inn as of April 11.
A thorough search was conducted, and among 8 applicants, Empire Golf Inc., located in Rancho Murietta near Sacramento, was eventually chosen. (See related story HERE.) The vetting process was exhaustive. Members of the search committee visited the various golf and dining facilities, talked to players and personnel, walked the grounds, observed up close the operation and tasted the food of the respective restaurants.
Once a flourishing restaurant, the newly rebuilt clubhouse and restaurant became a drain on the “for profit” Golf Club Corporation. People complained that the food was not nearly as good as it used to be, and the formal dining room closed down.
Tony Jenks was upbeat and optimistic that the board had done the right thing in hiring out the daily responsibilities and choosing Empire Golf, Inc. to do just that. And while the management company, which signed a 5-year contract, has the mandate to run a first class facility, the Oakmont Golf Club retains oversight over all aspects of the businesses.
As for the financial side, the $96,000 annual management fee is more than offset in savings, from accounting to workers compensation. And if management can prove that net earnings have surpassed the previous year, they receive a 15 percent incentive pay, a bonanza not only for Empire, Inc., but also for the club, namely, one dollar paid out begets $5.67 in profit.
But the good news does not end with Empire Golf Inc. Remember the $3.4 million obligation due in 2008? (The debt was incurred in remodeling the little restaurant into the stately Quail Inn and building a new pro shop). The board came up with the simplest of simple solutions, that is to ask the note holders and club members for an extension on their loans. A process is underway to arrange for lengthening the pay back until 2018 at a six percent interest rate, or to 2033 at seven percent, respectively.
Considering that the stock market returns over the past 30 years have amounted to an average of six percent, this is by any account a good investment. Indeed, owners of $1.6 million in papers have already indicated a willingness to sign up for the new plan. With half of it potentially raised, a financial institution may be inclined to extend a loan if such should even become necessary.
Additionally, the club has made great strides in signing up new golf members. A change in the bylaws as of January 1, 2005, allows non-resident golfers to become full club members. Remarkably, 108 resident and non-resident people have already taken advantage of this unique opportunity in the last three months.
With professional management running the golfing and restaurant facilities, hopes are high that with skilled staff for marketing, management and dining operation, the restaurant will once again become a favorite destination and the golf course a thriving enterprise.
Where in the wine country can you truly play the East course in the morning, have a wonderful lunch at a great restaurant, and play another 18 holes on the West course in the setting sun? Only in Oakmont.
There is nothing new with the OGC, just more of the same promises and unmet expectations.
And now it’s thirteen years later, 2018: Empire is gone, replaced by Kemper (but for how much longer?). Tom Jenks as Manager is gone, followed by Mike Ash, John Theilade, and now we have Greg Anderson. The Quail Inn never achieved the expectations of high quality and today survives on weddings, Newcomers, and Barbara Friday events. What is wrong? If you ask the OGC board, it’s the rain or the fires or the embezzlement or the accounting errors or …. as Roseann Roseannadanda from Saturday Night Live used to say, “it’s always sumthin’!”
Oakmont needs to learn from the sad history of the OGC and not get financially committed to bailing them out. Otherwise we will enter the neverending story of pouring good money after bad. Time for the OGC to face reality, downsize and consolidate courses, revenue, and expenses, and give up the idea that somehow, someway, retaining 36 holes of golf for a dwindling special interest group makes any kind of financial sense.
Julie,
Appreciate your excellent summary and insights.
Unless OGC commits fully and objectively to substantial changes in its ‘mentality’ and operations, then even its demanded bailout of many million of $$ from the OVA community cannot save it from itself.
Our bailout $$ — over whose use we’d have no control — will be simply wasted by OGC on their ‘same old same old’ and ‘let the good times roll’ approach to running a commercial business.
If you think things are bad, politically, here in Oakmont now, if the
OGC gets resident funds to prolong their failing business, I see the community coming apart. Much more will be lost than the GC. If the Oakmont BOD
really believes that a “bailout” will be a great investment, and if they MUST do this, let them do it by “including” these payments in our already established general budget, instead of increasing our already considerable homeowner’s dues.
This entire OGC / OBOD boondoggle is another clear reason for
potential Oakmont home owners to take another look and pass on buying here. Taking on debt is one thing, buying into a disaster is simply stupid.
I am watching this “situation” very carefully, as
I am sure many are. I am trying desperately to stay ahead of the
fallout if this disastrous adventure by the OGC / OBOD is realized…
There is something very wrong and dirty going on here…
Let me be among the first, (of many residents) who will say “goodbye” to Oakmont, if the OBOD fails to stop this bailout madness.
My house will be up for sale immediately….
Yes, I will be among the first (smart) rats to abandon a sinking ship…