Oakmont’s Golf Enterprise Part 2: Golf Lease Negotiations Leave Oakmont Members Waiting Outside

Oakmont's Golf Enterprise Part 2

In Part 1 of Oakmont’s Golf Enterprise, I examined who benefits, who pays, and who carries the risk. This follow-up looks at the revised CourseCo agreement, Gary Smith’s latest golf report, and changes to resident access and services.

Oakmont members pay for the golf properties through their dues. Yet their preferences appear to have no visible place in the direction these negotiations are taking.

At the board meeting, members were told OVA was close to signing a memorandum of understanding with CourseCo, followed by a revised contract shaping the relationship for years. The explanation included: “More details will be shared with the membership after the MOU and final lease agreement are signed.”

After signing is too late to influence the agreement.

Negotiations have been announced, and some financial changes reported. But no membership preference survey, alternatives review, or opportunity to evaluate the proposed agreement was identified in this discussion. The arrangement affects members’ expenses, the condition of properties they financed, and community services.

Whose priorities guide the negotiations

Members have different priorities. Some want better golf conditions. Others value dining, gathering space, walking access, or protection of the landscape. Many want predictable costs and limits on future dues exposure.

How have those preferences been measured and translated into negotiating instructions? What balance is being sought between commercial operations, resident benefits, and affordability?

The public discussion did not answer those questions. Without a demonstrated process for gathering member preferences, the direction appears to be set by those negotiating, with the membership receiving the explanation afterward. There may be an assumption by OVA members of added financial risk with new obligations.

Contract negotiations can require confidentiality. That does not prevent the board from explaining its objectives, gathering resident preferences, or presenting financial consequences before signing. Members do not need access to every negotiating exchange to have a meaningful voice.

A favorable year without public financial figures

Golf Advisory Committee representative Gary Smith said the committee met with the lessee’s management November 10 to review nine-month results. He described a favorable year, consistent golf participation, renewed tournament activity, and strong banquet business, with bookings into 2027 and 2028.

A successful business year does not establish that OVA’s total payments, property expenses, and future capital obligations represent good value for residents.

The October budget announcement described OVA assuming property insurance, taxes, and some grounds and waterway maintenance while reducing social-membership payments from $8.50 to $7 per member monthly. The relevant calculation is the net result after transferred expenses, including foreseeable future costs. No estimation has been given to OVA members that pay the bills.

Capital spending and the missing replacement plan

Smith said the lessee had fulfilled approximately 60% of its estimated 2026 capital-investment obligation, based on the previous year’s gross revenue. Much of that spending went toward restoring the irrigation well at hole 17.

The report did not provide the dollar requirement, credited expenditures, or remaining work. The percentage alone does not establish a lease violation; the deadline and accounting must be checked. It also does not establish that long-term replacement needs are adequately funded. And its November now and how will CourseCo complete the other 40%?

During questions, concerns were raised about uneven and dangerous cart paths. Smith explained that the major Sugarloaf problem involved replacing thousands of feet, including removing existing paths, rather than simply patching them. Members were not given its cost or funding plan.

Who must pay? Is funding accumulated? Will the revised agreement leave this obligation with the operator or expose members to another expense?

A current golf-property reserve study and condition assessment should help answer those questions. Members have still not been shown that comprehensive picture. An annual spending formula cannot substitute for identifying assets, replacement schedules, and necessary funding.

Smith also said he believed OVA contributed to work on the weir and pond at hole 2, helping reduce the operator’s purchased-water needs. The board should provide the actual contribution, funding account, and allocation of responsibility. How much did OVA members pay in addition to the hundreds of thousands spent on subsidy social membership fees?

Reduced winter access and dining

The Valley of the Moon Club website specifies winter changes beginning December 1, 2026.

The VOM golf shop will open daily from 7 a.m. to 5 p.m. The Sugarloaf golf shop will close for winter, reopening March 1. Golfers playing either course will check in at VOM, with Sugarloaf using modified routing beginning at hole 4. The Sugarloaf course remains open; its golf shop is closing.

The Oak restaurant’s winter schedule will be:

Monday, Thursday, Friday and Saturday: 11:30 a.m. to 6 p.m.
Sunday: 11:30 a.m. to 5 p.m.
TUESDAY AND WEDNESDAY: CLOSED.

Premade food and beverages will be available in the VOM golf shop on Tuesdays and Wednesdays. The dated winter notice supersedes the earlier hours still displayed on separate dining and contact pages.

Smith described the Tuesday and Wednesday closures as new. Seasonal reductions may have a business justification. But what minimum dining access does the social-membership payment guarantee, and who approves changes?

Advertised resident benefits include dining discounts, social activities, and clubhouse use when not otherwise scheduled. Before a new agreement is completed, members should be asked which services and access they value enough to support collectively. Of course this was not done.

Accountability before the signatures

The discussion also raised uncertainty about how OVA directs Oakmont Village Property Corporation, which holds the golf properties, and how the corporations get needed work accomplished. Smith suggested this might be part of negotiations.

That exchange leaves the public explanation incomplete. Who orders major repairs, approves expenditures, enforces the lease, and answers when obligations are unmet?

Before signing, the board should publish negotiating objectives, current and proposed financial responsibilities, and the services members will receive. It should disclose the capital assessment and funding assumptions, then provide a genuine opportunity for member feedback to influence the result.

Oakmont members financed ownership of these properties. Their preferences should help determine what that ownership delivers. An announcement after signing is notification. Participation requires an opportunity to influence it beforehand.


Sources

OVA board meeting transcript, November 17, 2026. Lease announcement at approximately 11:47–12:07; Gary Smith’s report and ensuing questions at approximately 37:57–46:09. OVA meeting records and videos:
https://oakmontvillage.com/

Valley of the Moon Club, winter operating notice effective December 1, 2026, checked November 18, 2026. Source for the exact winter hours, golf check-in location, and Sugarloaf routing:
https://www.playvom.com/

Valley of the Moon Club, separate dining page displaying the earlier schedule at the time checked:
https://www.playvom.com/the-club/dining

Valley of the Moon Club, resident social-membership benefits:
https://www.playvom.com/membership/social-membership

Oakmont News, Board Approves 2027 Budget, October 20, 2026:
https://oakmontvillage.com/article/board-approves-2027-budget/

Deborah Quam, Oakmont’s Golf Enterprise Who Benefits Who Pays and Who Carries the Risk, November 9, 2026:
https://oakmontobserver.com/oakmonts-golf-enterprise/


Share this page:

Leave a Comment